Brad Roth was 23, had recently left Merrill Lynch and, by his own account, had never negotiated anything. His only debts had been the house he lived in, car payments and some credit card balances. Then he and a partner agreed to buy an insurance brokerage, and he had to borrow about $2.5 million to do it. Signing those papers, he says, was probably when he first became an adult.
On Episode 322 of The Exit, host Steve McGarry talks with Roth, now founder and chief investment officer of THOR Financial Technologies, about the roughly 10 years he spent running that business before selling it in 2023 for over $1 million. His main lesson for owners: run the business as if a buyer could ask for anything at any time, long before a sale is on the table.
A deal financed by an insurance company, not a bank
Roth had planned to start a goals-based investing company after Merrill Lynch. Instead, someone he had known for years, who already owned an insurance brokerage, called with a chance to acquire another one and add financial services as a cross-sell. He asked Roth to be his partner.
They did not go to a bank. Roth says an insurance company that needed the business to “perpetuate” was willing to put up the money for them to borrow; he describes the owner as “slightly older.” The insurer’s M&A staff and attorneys helped underwrite the deal and shape the purchase agreements, though negotiations still took about six months. McGarry compared it to a seller-financing hybrid. Roth’s view is that someone in their early 20s would probably never have got that much financing without such a specific need on the other side.
If you are buying without that help, pay for it
Most young buyers will not have a lender with an in-house deal team. Roth’s advice to someone borrowing cold is to find a local CPA or another third party to work through the numbers with them, and to pay for that work even when money is tight. In his view, the hardest part is getting comfortable with the financials. Understanding the real economic benefit makes the risk feel manageable, and a poor choice, he says, “could be catastrophic.”
Six years to make a 110-year-old business run without him
The brokerage was 110 years old when Roth arrived. He remembers stacks of paper, roughly 138 file cabinets and one monitor per person. Making it efficient enough to run without him took about six years. After that, he spent a handful of hours a week in the business, “still managing it, still being present. But it didn’t rely on me.” That freed him to start THOR as a bootstrapped company.
It also shapes his view of exit preparation. It does not have to start on day one, he says, but it has to start early. He is wary of owners who decide to sell in a year and only then start cutting costs, documenting processes and taking their accounting seriously; those are “things you should be doing all of the time.”
Roth calls this running the business in an “institutional” manner, with decisions recorded and files where people expect them. His test is due diligence: when a buyer arrives with forty questions and a checklist, “if you can get that to them in under a week, they know that you have your stuff together.” A buyer, he adds, will be more comfortable if the business can keep performing without the founder.
When two long-time employees passed away
That preparation was tested in a way Roth did not plan for. Two long-standing employees, who had been at the brokerage since before he bought it, passed away. Insurance is a relationship business, and he describes the calls to clients as very hard.
If the business had still looked as it did on his first day, with filing cabinets in the basement, he says, “it would have been almost impossible to be able to figure out what was where, who to service, and it would have been a nightmare.” Because it had been digitized, with the CRM and workflows set up and files labeled and dated, the remaining service staff could keep clients looked after while he hired. Roth treats losing a key employee as much the same problem as a founder leaving.
Why he listened to one inbound offer
Roth was not trying to sell. But THOR was starting to scale, and after losing those two employees he concluded the brokerage needed someone else to lead it. When a prospective acquirer approached him, he decided to listen. Due diligence took about 90 days, and he sold the business in its 10th year. According to the bio his team provided for the episode, the sale closed in 2023 for over $1 million; the buyer was not named. He says the transaction took some stress off him and let him give THOR his full attention.
The growth he says he left on the table
Asked about mistakes, Roth names two. He was too slow to let go of people who no longer fit the culture. And he played defense. The brokerage had healthy recurring revenue and, he says, retained 98% of its clients on an annualized basis. “We doubled the business, but we probably could have quadrupled the business,” he says, and he believes more aggressive growth early on would have meant a better result at exit.
For an owner thinking about a sale, the lessons fit together. Organized records and a team that can work without you protect the business when something goes wrong and make diligence faster. Steady cash flow is valuable, but in Roth’s view it is not a reason to stop pushing for growth.
Learn more about Brad Roth at bradroth.co and about THOR Financial Technologies at thorft.com. He is the author of Little Reasons, Big Consequences, hosts the Behind the Ticker podcast, and is on X at @bradr_thor.

